Gaming

GTA 6 Reviews vs Players: 99 on Metacritic, But Only 54.5% of Players Are Happy

Published By Shivam Sharma8 min read
GTA 6 reviews vs players — a player on a couch facing a glowing TV at night

GTA 6 has two verdicts, and they do not agree. The critics gave it a 99 on Metacritic, the highest score of any release in 2026. Launch-day social posts across six social platforms split almost down the middle among posts that took a side: 54.5 percent favourable, 45.5 percent unfavourable, according to PeakMetrics. Both numbers are real, but they measure different things: a critic score against a share of side-taking posts. The gap between them is the story of this launch.

That gap is not a mystery once you look at what each side was judging. The critics judged the game. The players judged the game running on their own consoles, on launch night, with clips showing frame rates dropping. The PS5 sign-in failures were a separate access problem, not a game defect.

What the critics said

The critical consensus is about as strong as it gets. GTA VI landed a 99 on Metacritic, and USA Today reported that the 99 came from 150 critics. On OpenCritic, 99 percent of 88 critics recommend the game. PeakMetrics notes that the game landed a 99 on Metacritic, the highest-rated release of 2026, and also holds a record score on OpenCritic.

Two of the most-quoted individual verdicts show the same positive reaction. Jason Schreier called it “one of the greatest games” he has ever played, and Brazil’s O Globo called it a masterpiece, according to PeakMetrics. The industry agreed before the game was even out: GTA VI was nominated for eight Game Awards on 17 November, two days before release, including Game of the Year and Best Game Direction, according to GameWatcher.

None of that is in dispute. What is in dispute is what the scores left out, and that is where the players come in.

What the players said

PeakMetrics analysed social conversation about GTA 6 from 11 November through launch day, across X, Reddit, Bluesky, Instagram, Facebook and TikTok, with launch-day data running through mid-afternoon Pacific time. Among launch-day posts that took a side, 54.5 percent were favourable and 45.5 percent were unfavourable. Launch day drew about six times the conversation of a normal pre-launch day, so this is not a small sample talking. It is the loudest day in the game’s history, and nearly half of it was negative.

Most of the criticism was about performance, not the game itself. Talk about frame drops and stutter jumped about 55 times on launch day compared with a typical day before launch. About 23 percent of the launch-day storylines PeakMetrics tracked were about access or technical problems, including crashes, stutter and trouble getting into the game. The frame-rate complaints centered on player clips showing the game running at 15 to 20 frames per second on a base PS5. PeakMetrics found streamers sharing clips of bugs and slowdowns, and comparisons to Cyberpunk 2077’s rocky launch showed up fast.

A smaller share of the criticism was about value: the $80 to $100 price, physical copies that ship without a disc, content locked behind premium editions and a PC version that is still months away. PC timing made up about 8 percent of launch-day storyline conversation, according to PeakMetrics.

The favourable side was loud too, and it had very little to do with frame rates. The soundtrack became a breakout story, with Camila Cabello’s new song, Asake’s “Joha” on the in-game radio, JENNIE’s “Power Trip” and the Afrobeats station AfroBank FM among the most-shared positive posts. NPC clips were mistaken for real footage, the graphics were described again and again as looking real, and even the in-game phone’s interface got praise. Some of the most telling posts came from former skeptics publicly taking back what they had said about Rockstar.

The gap, in one table

Put the two verdicts side by side and the split becomes a number you can point at.

Measure Figure Source
Metacritic critic score 99 out of 100 150 critics, via USA Today
OpenCritic recommend rate 99% 88 critics, via USA Today
Player-favourable share 54.5% PeakMetrics, launch-day posts taking a side
Player-unfavourable share 45.5% PeakMetrics, launch-day posts taking a side
Gap, critic score vs player-favourable share 44.5 points Our calculation

The gap is 44.5 points, by our calculation: a 99 from the critics against 54.5 percent favourable from the players. The two numbers measure different things, a critic score against a share of side-taking posts, so treat the gap as a shorthand, not a like-for-like comparison. The performance conversation explains most of it. Frame-drop and stutter talk rose about 55 times on launch day while overall GTA 6 conversation rose about 6 times, so performance talk grew about 9 times faster than the conversation as a whole, by our calculation. When one complaint grows nine times faster than everything else, it is the complaint driving the split.

Nearly a quarter of the launch-day storylines PeakMetrics tracked were access or technical problems, at about 23 percent. That is roughly one in four storylines about getting into the game, staying in it, or watching it stutter.

The bugs behind the complaints

The bug reports are player reports and clips, not a verified list from Rockstar, and that distinction matters. Rockstar has not issued a statement on the bugs or published known-issues notes, according to Moneycontrol. What players have reported, consistently across outlets, is a recognisable pattern.

The most common complaint, in player reports, involves characters dropping through the ground. Several players said Lucia fell through the map during the prologue, with a mission restart being the only fix when she failed to respawn. Other clips players shared show Jason and a police officer merging and sliding through a couch, a ship wedged at an angle on a bridge, and a car launched into the air after a crash. Some players flagged an early Lucia mission that they said cannot be completed after leaving a bank, along with missing textures, audio issues and lost progress, Moneycontrol reported.

GameWatcher found the same pattern in a bug megathread, where players described repeated crashes during the opening prologue, freezing, and a softlock during an early Lucia mission that prevented progression after leaving a bank, plus missing textures, audio problems and lost progress, reported on both PS5 and Xbox Series X/S. A launch-day bug compilation includes footage of aircraft passing through buildings, characters falling beneath the map, NPCs swimming sideways, and vehicles launching into the air following collisions.

Access was a separate problem, and it was a platform problem, not a game bug. PS5 sign-in failures, showing a “services are busy” message, were reported from roughly 17:00 UTC on 18 November, while the platform status pages showed normal service at 01:40 UTC on 19 November, according to GTA6Games.org. No statement came from Sony or Rockstar. Separately, players also needed PS5 firmware 14.23 (26.07-14.23.00), a 1.267 GB update released on 17 November, to start the game at all.

Why the scores look strange

Some of the highest scores carry their own contradictions. Push Square awarded the game 10 out of 10 while listing a padded story, the lack of a 60 FPS option, and bullet-sponge enemies among its negatives. Multiplayer.it awarded a perfect 100 with the tagline “Grand Theft Auto 6 isn’t a perfect game.” Both are reported by GameWatcher, and both show a scoring system that can call a game perfect while listing what is wrong with it.

The review process itself drew criticism. Rockstar limited review code to predominantly well-known publications, GameWatcher reported.

A smaller group of unfavourable posts went further and claimed reviewers had been paid off. That is a claim by players, not an established fact, and it should be read as frustration rather than evidence. No outlet has produced proof of paid reviews, and the claim says more about the gap between the scores and the experience than it does about any individual reviewer. One viral post that did not survive scrutiny came from streamer ohnePixel, who claimed GTA VI has a mission with a “no fail” state; players pointed out that the footage actually shows the failure outcome, according to GameWatcher.

The fairest reading is simpler than the conspiracy version. The critics played a great game before launch. The players played the same great game on launch night, on their own consoles, with clips showing frame rates dropping. Both verdicts are understandable. They just describe different days.

Should I buy GTA 6 on a base PS5 right now?

If you own a base PS5, wait before buying GTA 6. The game itself earned a 99 on Metacritic, but launch-day player clips show 15 to 20 frames per second on a base PS5, and Rockstar has published no patch or known-issues list yet.

  1. Wait before you buy the game, and check whether Rockstar has published a patch or a known-issues list first.
  2. Check whether your console is a base PS5, because the 15-to-20-frame player clips come from that hardware.
  3. Watch a few minutes of unedited base PS5 gameplay, and judge the frame rate with your own eyes.
  4. Keep your receipt and your packaging, in case your copy has a problem and you need to return it.
  5. Play the prologue first, and restart the mission if Lucia falls through the map and cannot respawn.

What to watch next is whether a patch comes. PeakMetrics put it plainly: the next few days will decide which version of the GTA 6 launch sticks, and the big question is whether Rockstar patches the PS5 frame drops quickly. Rockstar has announced nothing about a patch, so whether one comes quickly is unknown. If it does, the performance complaints may fade and the conversation may shift toward the game itself, which is where fans are already happiest. If it does not, the 44.5-point difference between the critic score and the player-favourable share could harden into the story of this launch, and the 99 on Metacritic could be remembered as the score the players did not recognise.